ETF or Index Fund: Which Is Right for You?


The similarities and differences between the ETF or Index Fund, which are great options for both stock market beginners and experts, are mentioned in our article.


Table of Contents

ETF or Index Fund: Which Is Right for You?

What do ETFs and index funds have in common?

Differences between index funds and ETFs

Final Thoughts


Exchange-traded funds and index funds are a great way for stock market beginners and experts alike, but if you're committed to invest, there are some tips to consider before you get started.

You are probably wondering which exchange-traded funds or index funds, also known as ETFs, are the better investment for you? The truth is, there are more similarities than differences between the two. However, there are a few considerations that may help you decide.


What do ETFs and index funds have in common?

First of all, let's talk about the similarities. ETFs and index funds combine many individual investments, such as stocks or bonds, into a single investment, and they are seen as a popular choice for investors for several common reasons:

  • Diversification. Just a few index funds or ETFs can provide a highly diversified portfolio. For instance, an ETF based on the S&P 500 will let you see hundreds of the nation's largest firms.
  • Low cost. Index funds and ETFs are passively managed. This means that Index funds and ETFs are passively managed. This can be compared to an actively managed form. Here a human broker actively chooses what to invest in and then results in higher costs for the investor in the form of expense ratios. There are several actively managed ETFs, but for this comparison, we need to focus on the more common passively managed variety. The average annual expense ratio of passively managed funds was 0.15%, compared to the average expense ratio of actively managed funds of 0.67% in 2018. 
  • Strong long-term returns. If we talk about long-term investors, passively managed index funds are in the tendency to outperform actively managed mutual funds. Passively managed investments track the ups and downs of the index they follow, and these indices have shown positive returns historically. For instance, the annual total return of the S&P 500 has averaged around 10% over the last 90 years.

Actively managed mutual funds may show better performance in the short run because fund managers make investment decisions based on current market conditions and their own expertise. However, the impossibility of fund managers to make consistent, out-of-market decisions over a long period of time can lead to lower returns over time compared to passively managed funds.


Differences between index funds and ETFs


Although ETFs and index funds have many of the same benefits, there are a few differences between the two to be aware of.


  1. The way of how to buy and sell.

The biggest difference between ETFs and index funds is that ETFs are traded during the day like stocks, while index funds can only be bought and ended at the price determined at the end of the trading day. For long-term investors, this issue is not so important or alarming. Buying or selling at noon or 4:00 pm will likely have little impact on the value of the investment in 20 years. However, if you are interested in intraday trading, ETFs are a better option to turn to.

The best decision is that both ETFs and index funds are great for long-term investments. With ETFs, investors have the option to buy and sell throughout the day. Despite the fact that they trade like stocks, ETFs are generally a less risky selection in the long run than buying and vending the stocks of individual firms.


  1. The minimum investment required.

ETFs will have a lower minimum investment than index funds. Often, all it takes to invest in an ETF is the amount needed to purchase a single share. If we are talking about the index funds, however, brokers often set minimums that can be slightly higher than a typical share price. For instance, Vanguard has a minimum investment of $3,000 for most index funds, whereas T. Rowe Price has a minimum initial investment of $2,500.

There are online brokers available with no minimum initial investments. If you only have a small amount to invest, think about two selections: an ETF with a share price you can afford, or an index fund with no minimum investment amount.

  1. The capital gains taxes you’ll pay.

Thanks to the way they are structured, ETFs are inherently more efficient than index funds. When you sell an ETF, you usually sell it to another investor who bought it, and the cash comes directly from them. Capital gains taxes from this sale will naturally be yours alone.

In order to take cash from the index fund, you should use it from the fund manager. This fund will then have to sell securities to generate the money that will be paid out to you. When this sale is for a profit, the net gains are passed to every investor who owns a stake in the fund.

  1. The cost of owning them.

Both ETFs and index funds can be very inexpensive to own in terms of expense ratio.

While buying ETFs, you will also be exposed to a cost called the bid-ask spread, which you will not see when buying index funds. But, if you're buying high-volume, broad-market ETFs, the expense is usually very small.


Final Thoughts

In conclusion, if we talk about index funds and ETFs, they are low-cost options compared to the most actively managed mutual funds. If you want to decide between ETFs and index funds, compare each fund's expense ratio, as this is an ongoing cost that you will pay for as long as you hold the investment. In addition, it will be very useful for you to check the commissions you will pay to buy or sell the investment. However, these fees are usually less important unless you buy and sell frequently.

We hope that this blog post will be beneficial for you. We will continue to create useful works in order to get inspired by everyone. We are sure that we will achieve splendid things altogether. Keep on following Finage for the best and more.  


You can start building your own trade application with Finage free Index and ETFs API key.

Build with us today!

Get a Free API key